黑洞社区

What鈥檚 this 鈥渇ramework鈥� idea all about? I was at the launching of the JCT Framework Agreement (2007), and I didn鈥檛 know much about it. A fellow guest whispered 鈥淲hy didn鈥檛 they call it a term contract?鈥� Don鈥檛 ask me. Next day I noticed in 黑洞社区 that one or two cute people had plugged into 拢9.5bn of construction work with Spanish-owned BAA (18 January 2008). But I鈥檓 still none the wiser about framework agreements. The JCT is keen, though, hence its 16-page document thingy.

It鈥檚 an umbrella. But not a standalone umbrella. The framework umbrella sits neatly above a sailing dinghy. And in the dinghy is the construction enterprise: the architect, the PQS and the employer. They are all reading the ordinary standard form JCT contract (the ones that you are familiar with).

In short, there are two lots of agreements to be agreed. It is my guess that for all that 拢9.5bn BAA work, the nine companies involved are still mere contenders for some of that work. A framework deal is, in my old-fashioned language, a 鈥渃all-off鈥� deal. The potential winners of work have agreed what I will call basic ingredients. But they haven鈥檛 yet won any work. It may even be that having got a framework in place, no work is won at all. A framework deal is an 鈥渋f鈥� deal. It鈥檚 more or less like you saying to me: 鈥淟et鈥檚 do a deal whereby if we need an adjudicator next year we have already agreed your terms.鈥� So, we have a call-off deal.

Credit: Simone Lia

So, having got the umbrella up and agreed, what next? The JCT explains that the employer will issue an enquiry to what it calls 鈥渢he provider鈥� in the dinghy. The enquiry sets out the specific works. It may be that the umbrella has agreed basic prices and costs. So, if Laing O鈥橰ourke is asked to fix a door knob at Stansted airport, the framework has pre-agreed the price. If Carillon is asked to build another runway, the framework may have laid down which JCT form will apply, may have priced the canteen costs, the staff, the huts, the price of the concrete. Truth to tell, it doesn鈥檛 matter how detailed the framework agreement is. The idea is to somehow short circuit the actual or eventual contract value. Having worked out the actual price on the call-off system, all that is needed is the order to build the runway or fix the door knob.

What鈥檚 the big idea behind all this? The JCT says it鈥檚 all down to Sir John Egan and his Rethinking Construction report. He challenged the way we have done things hitherto in our industry. Oh, he had a sound point. Instead of doing one-off work (invariably won at the lowest bid by the outfit that dropped the biggest clanger when estimating the job) he thought it better to 鈥渂e together鈥�. Better to move teamlike from project to project. He said: 鈥淔ragmentation of production roles and processes tends to bring contractual relations to the fore, further inhibiting effective and efficient team-working, sharing of information and know-how.鈥�

This is grand stuff. All we need in the dinghy is that bulldog in the television commercial that says 鈥極h yes鈥� 鈥�
And now for what happens in real life

JCT Framework Agreements makes a similar point: 鈥淭he focus tends to be on contractual demarcation lines and responsibilities, rather than working together to meet the client鈥檚 needs in the most effective and/or efficient manner.鈥� Frameworks enable project participants to take a longer view, to build and develop relationships, to 鈥渆nhance the reputations and commercial opportunities of all concerned鈥�. This is grand stuff. All we need in the dinghy now is that smiling bulldog in the television commercial that says 鈥淥h yes鈥�.

And now let me tell you what will happen in real life. Happily, an estimator somewhere is going to help to compile a four-year call-off framework price list 鈥� and lock his outfit into an awfully big mistake. It鈥檚 a fixed price four-year call-off term contract. As soon as it is realised that any one job under the umbrella is going to take a cold bath, folk will begin to wriggle. Hold on, says the construction chief, this deal will bring a profit on the next job. But it doesn鈥檛. Oh misery! Oh wet dinghy! Man overboard!

I do wish Egan well but we in construction are fond of fighting. The JCT gets 10 out of 10 for trying 鈥� but the JCT is not in the dinghy, and it gets damp down here.