黑洞社区

The chief executive of Vinci has said Carillion being listed on the Stock Exchange helped send it under because City demands forced it into chasing unrealistic growth.

Vinci is listed on the Paris stock exchange and published its first half results at the end of last week with revenue in the six months to June growing 7% to 鈧�19.8bn (拢17.6bn) with earnings up close to 5% to 鈧�2.9bn (拢2.6bn).

But Bruno Dupety, the boss of Vinci鈥檚 拢1bn turnover UK construction business, said listed contractors in the UK are being hampered by investors demanding firms spell out growth plans for the coming years.

鈥淭here is something wrong with the British system,鈥� the Frenchman said. 鈥淸Listed firms] are encouraged by the City to grow. Growth is not virtuous. The right approach is to manage the job you are taking, not to satisfy the City. But [listed firms] have to tell a story which will please investors.鈥�

He added he was 鈥渟urprised鈥� by Carillion鈥檚 implosion and said: 鈥淲hat they were disclosing at the beginning of 2017 was quite nice. [But] I think they took jobs at prices which were just impossible.鈥�

And he said Carillion was too willing to take on risk from public sector contracts 鈥� with the firm鈥檚 collapse shining a light on those public sector clients who don鈥檛 share enough risk with their builders.

In 2016, Carillion had revenue of 拢1.72bn from the UK public sector 鈥� around 45% of its UK income 鈥� which involved working on more than 400 contracts.

Dupety (pictured) said: 鈥淚 think Carillion has accepted conditions which are too difficult to manage. The public sector should be more flexible and fairer in managing their contracts. It鈥檚 not the case. [A lot] push all the risk on to the main contractor.鈥�

And he said public sector bodies needed to trust their own judgment more, rather than rely on a team of advisors.

鈥淚n this country, they rely on external bodies. Why do they do that? In this country, they鈥檙e more confident in what an adviser tells them than their own judgment. For them, it鈥檚 protection.鈥�

Dupety arrived in the UK at the end of 2014 after Vinci racked up huge losses on its scheme to extend the Nottingham tram network under a PFI deal.

Vinci completed construction work three years ago but Dupety confirmed the scheme is still not off the contractor鈥檚 books.

He declined to go into details but said the decision to sign the deal in the first place was 鈥渇oolish鈥�. He said the firm took too much risk on a job 鈥� which has seen it rack up in excess of 拢200m in losses 鈥� in particular the dangers of working with utilities such as water, gas and electricity.

鈥淭aking the risk of utilities is just foolish. You don鈥檛 know where they are. You鈥檙e taking a risk on something you have no control [over].鈥�