The hoo haa surrounding the unveiling of HOK's 'compelling bowl' at the Olympic site left 黑洞社区's reporter feeling strangely umoved

Stratford in November is a dark and grimy place. It doesn鈥檛 get much better when you reach the Olympic site. Travelling there by bus with the world鈥檚 media yesterday, I saw a Nuttalls excavator pushing soil around the site like a child playing with its food. For a site that will be a hive of activity in less than a year鈥檚 time, there didn鈥檛 seem to be an awful lot going on.

But all that is about to change. An excited press officer at the front of the bus started pointing at piles of silt. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 where the Aquatics Centre will be,鈥 he said. 鈥淎nd there鈥檒l be a fantastic bridge here.鈥

If those Nuttalls excavators ever stop working, Armitt could probably dig the foundations himself with his king-size mitts.

We eventually pulled up outside an even bigger mound of earth, where the ODA had positioned one of their draughty, modern tents. This is where the eyes of the world would be introduced to the Olympic Stadium. We piled in, all of us, waiting for Coe, Armitt, Jowell et al to pull the collective sheets off what we were promised would be the 鈥渉eart of the Olympic site鈥.

This was the first time I鈥檇 seen ODA chairman John Armitt perform in the flesh, and he strikes rather a more authoritative figure than David Higgins. He鈥檚 also quite straightforward, which is a welcome change from the other, obsessively media-managed directors. Furthermore, he has the most enormous hands I鈥檝e ever seen. If those Nuttalls excavators ever stop working, Armitt could probably dig the foundations himself with his king-size mitts.

Rod Sheard, HOK Sport鈥檚 principal architect, stood to introduce us to his 鈥渃ompelling bowl鈥 鈥 his words, not mine.

Seb Coe, whose hands are rather more dainty, told the press corps we were sitting on the exact point where, in five years time, the 100m runners would be reaching the finishing line. No-one quite knew how to react. It was certainly the closest any of us corpulent columnists would come to Olympic glory.

Seconds later, the first image of the stadium flashed up on the screen. It was greeted by a religious hush. Were we supposed to applaud? No-one did. Rod Sheard, HOK Sport鈥檚 principal architect, stood to introduce us to his 鈥渃ompelling bowl鈥 鈥 his words, not mine. Sheard had dressed down for the occasion, favouring a blue polo shirt and pink jumper over the suits everyone else had turned up in. A quiet, genial Australian, he wasn鈥檛 quite prepared for the onslaught of questioning from the hacks in the front row. Where鈥檚 the roof, Rod? Was it too expensive? Someone asked if he could tell us what the build cost was going to be? Sheard bit his lip. Armitt shook his head curtly. 鈥淚鈥檝e no idea,鈥 smiled Sheard. I imagine several sets of feet were stamping on his at that moment. And if Armitt鈥檚 feet are the size of his hands, that鈥檚 one hell of a message.

Finally, we were shown a video presentation of the constituent parts of the stadium flying past London landmarks, twirling up the river and connecting themselves in the green fields of Stratford. If only it was going to be as easy to construct as that, I thought. In general, the whole thing left me strangely unmoved. Here it was, the heart of the Olympic site, but my pulse-rate stayed exactly the same.

Sunand Prasad

鈥淚 am heartened to see how this design has developed over the last few months. It is an intelligent response that meets both the large scale needs of the games and the legacy needs of having a stadium of the right size and atmosphere. It is the first time this approach has been taken and this something to celebrate. It is an excellent design and still evolving. We hope it will continue to develop in the way that the illustrations promise and not be compromised by 鈥榲alue engineering鈥."

Tarek Merlin

"It鈥檚 obviously a great shame we鈥檝e lost the magic (of the foreign office design), and ended up with this. It鈥檚 very standard, there鈥檚 no architecture in it. That鈥檚 the problem with these bids, you get so excited by the imagery and then end up with something far less interesting. If you ran these pictures side by side that鈥檇 be funny."

Chris Wilkinson, Wilkinson Eyre

鈥淚 think it鈥檚 ok for a low-budget stadium. Considering it鈥檚 only going to be used for a short period of time, I think it鈥檚 appropriate they made it look simple. It鈥檚 going to be small in the legacy bit. I think it鈥檚 quite clever they used fabric, it鈥檚 much easier to take down and reuse afterwards鈥